Cowbar residents split over cliff erosion plans near Staithes

Redcar and Cleveland Council to Realign Cowbar Lane

Redcar and Cleveland Council is accelerating plans to realign Cowbar Lane in Cowbar, near Staithes. An adopted coastal management strategy suggests moving the road away from the cliff edge in three stages.

Phase One Engineering Works

Phase one of the engineering works, estimated to cost £1.2 million, was initially scheduled for the early 2030s. However, after receiving updated advice on future erosion predictions, the council aims to complete it by 2027.

Community Concerns

Some residents have raised questions about the plans, which include purchasing and demolishing a cottage to reroute the road leading to Staithes harbour. The council is negotiating with the property owner and seeking funding from external partners like the Environment Agency.

Impact of Recent Events

Following a significant rock fall incident in October 2024, caused by waves up to 30 meters high and heavy rain, consultants Royal Haskoning/DHV were hired to assess the lane’s condition. Academics from Durham University are also monitoring the coast using advanced techniques like 3D laser scanning.

Geological Considerations

The cliffs at Cowbar consist of soft glacial till, sandstone, and shale. Previous stabilization measures are no longer effective. Rising sea levels due to global warming are another factor being considered.

Predictions and Safety Measures

Findings from Haskoning predict an average erosion of 0.1 meters per year, leading to concerns about an imminent cliff collapse. In May, the council installed fencing to prevent parking in a layby at the cliff’s edge.

Council Statements

A council spokesman stated there is a buffer zone between the cliff face and the road. They will assess the situation if further rock falls occur. Weekly inspections of the road are ongoing.

Property Purchase and Funding

The Local Democracy Reporting Service asked how the council would ensure value for money in the property purchase. The spokesman said the negotiated price reflects current market value in the Staithes area. The transaction requires final council approval and will be funded as part of the overall development scheme.

Design and Construction Timeline

The firm AtkinsRealisUK will design the realigned road and advise on utility relocations. The construction period is estimated at eight months.

Community Engagement

A steering group, including council representatives and local residents, meets regularly to discuss the project. A presentation indicated that a phased road realignment is the most economically viable and environmentally preferred option.

Coastal Erosion Risks

The council has classified coastal erosion as a corporate “red risk.” A report states this includes the risk of legal challenges and reputational damage from perceived inaction.

Community Perspectives

One resident expressed skepticism about the necessity of the proposed work, questioning why traffic is still allowed if erosion is so severe. Another resident noted anxiety in the community regarding the situation.

Historical Context

Colin Mann, a local landowner, has lived in Cowbar for 50 years. He previously formed a residents association and commissioned a study in 2006 on coastal retreat. He raised concerns about the effectiveness of rock armor installed in 2007.

Conclusion

The situation remains complex, with diverse opinions in the community. The North Sea and local residents are not going away, and a resolution is needed.